In a decision underscoring the complexity and risks of making environmental marketing claims, the National Advertising Division (NAD) issued a decision in a challenge brought by the International Bottled Water Association (IBWA) against Boxed Water is Better® (Boxed Water). In the case, the NAD addressed a slew of claims touching on recyclability, renewability, life cycle impact comparisons, puffery, and more.
Recyclability and the Green Guides
NAD substantiated Boxed Water’s claims that its cartons are “recyclable” and “100% recyclable,” finding that the claims were consistent with the Federal Trade Commission’s (FTC) Green Guides, which permit such statements if a substantial majority (defined as 60% or more) of consumers have access to appropriate recycling facilities. Despite the multilayered structure of the cartons and industry challenges separating materials, NAD determined that the key threshold was access—not actual practice.Continue Reading Recyclable, Renewable, Regulated: NAD Pokes Holes in Boxed Water’s Green Pitch